DOI links and retracted papers — a documented case lookup Gumi article dated 2026-10-23. FILES - doi-retraction-records.py: two live Crossref requests for one fixed pair. - doi-retraction-records-results.json: selected fields and computed observations. - doi-retraction-records-README.txt: sources, method and reading notes. All three are included at the root of doi-retraction-records.zip. RUN Tested with CPython 3.12.14, macOS 27.0.1, arm64. Uses the Python standard library and HTTPS access to api.crossref.org. python3 doi-retraction-records.py > records.json The script requests these two records and does not read publisher full text: https://api.crossref.org/works/10.1038/s41586-023-05742-0 https://api.crossref.org/works/10.1038/s41586-023-06774-2 The selected fields are DOI, title, type, published, published-online, published-print, update-to, relation and URL, where present in the response. Abstracts, author lists, full references and full publisher HTML/PDF files are not included in the package. It requires no credentials and makes no changes to external records. Network/HTTP/JSON errors terminate the run; they are never converted to a "not retracted" finding. The supplied snapshot was retrieved at 2026-10-23T12:10:57+00:00. Re-running changes the timestamp and may return changed source metadata. It is a fixed case lookup, not an arbitrary-DOI detector, a complete status service, or a scientific-quality assessment. No material experiment was run. 中文记录 原论文:10.1038/s41586-023-05742-0。 出版社页面标注在线发表于 2023-03-08,标题含 RETRACTED ARTICLE, 正文提示撤稿并链接至通知。另有 2023-03-09 的印刷日期元数据。 通知:10.1038/s41586-023-06774-2。 在线日期 2023-11-07;期号日期 2023-12-14。这些不是本次核查日期。 原论文与通知分别是两个对象,通知链接回原论文。 本次还通过 doi.org 实际请求了两个 DOI,均在重定向后返回 HTTP 200, 可读页面的最终规范路径分别为上述两个 nature.com/articles/ 页面。 本地请求经过了出版社的 cookie 处理,最终 URL 附带临时查询参数; 此处只记录稳定的规范路径,不把临时参数写成永久引用。 也读取了 Nature 的出版后更新政策 HTML。没有下载或验证原论文 PDF。 Crossmark 的功能与限制依据官方说明,没有声称亲自检验弹窗的全部状态。 日本語記録 原論文:10.1038/s41586-023-05742-0。 出版社ページのオンライン公開日は 2023-03-08。題名には RETRACTED ARTICLE が付き、本文の撤回表示は通知へリンクします。 印刷日メタデータは別に 2023-03-09 と記録されています。 通知:10.1038/s41586-023-06774-2。 オンライン公開日は 2023-11-07、号の日付は 2023-12-14。 いずれも今回の確認日ではありません。二つは別の対象です。 doi.org 経由でも二つを実際に取得し、リダイレクト後に HTTP 200 と 読める出版社ページを確認しました。最終の正規パスは、それぞれの nature.com/articles/ ページです。cookie 処理に由来する一時的な クエリ文字列は、恒久的な出典リンクには使っていません。 Nature の方針の HTML も読みましたが、原論文 PDF は取得・検証して いません。Crossmark の説明は公式資料に基づき、ダイアログの全状態を 自分で検査したと述べるものではありません。 OBSERVED METADATA Original relation: {}. Original update-to types in this snapshot: correction, expression_of_concern. Notice update-to includes two rows with: target DOI 10.1038/s41586-023-05742-0; type retraction; date 2023-11-07; one source retraction-watch and one source publisher. The linked publisher notice identifies the retraction. In this pair the two source rows refer to the same target/type/date event; they are not two independent retractions. The script's grouping key is only a descriptive comparison for this fixed pair, not a universal deduplication algorithm. BOUNDARIES AND NEGATIVE FINDINGS - Empty relation on the original record did not rule out the linked notice. - Old correction/concern entries did not rule out a later retraction notice. - Two metadata rows from different sources did not mean two events here. - HTTP 200 and a resolvable DOI did not establish current scientific validity. - No arbitrary other DOI, all databases, GUI citation tools, full Crossmark dialog state, publisher PDF, or underlying superconductivity result was tested. These are observations and limits of this case, not claims of exhaustive coverage. PRIMARY SOURCES (read 2026-10-23) DOI Foundation, What is a DOI: https://www.doi.org/the-identifier/what-is-a-doi/ DOI Handbook, persistence and resolution: https://www.doi.org/doi-handbook/html/ Original publisher record: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-023-05742-0 Publisher retraction notice: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-023-06774-2 Nature corrections/retractions and exceptional removal policy: https://www.nature.com/nature/editorial-policies/correction-and-retraction-policy Crossmark service and limitations: https://www.crossref.org/services/crossmark/ Crossref Retraction Watch update-to/source documentation: https://www.crossref.org/documentation/retrieve-metadata/retraction-watch/ Publisher pages establish the documented publication status; the selected API snapshot records the separate metadata observation. Reading suggestions in the article are analysis, not a measurement of all scholarly services.